← All articles
Weight loss

Calories or hormones? What really decides your weight after 40

Coach Adrian O'Mahony

By Coach Adrian O'Mahony · 247FitMe Blog

Coach Adrian smiling, leaning on an exercise ball
  • Is it calories, or is it your hormones?
  • It's the question everyone over 40 gets stuck on.
  • A landmark Canadian article from Precision Nutrition set out to settle it.
  • The answer: it's both, and they work together.
7,700calories in 1 kg of body fat
Your targetFirst we work out your fat-free weight, then we set your protein
20 minworkouts designed for your body, whatever your fitness level today

Calories still count after 40

  • Calories in versus calories out is true.
  • Eat less than your body uses, and the fat comes off.
  • 1 kg of body fat holds about 7,700 calories, as I explain in The ugly truth about fat.
  • But sleep, stress, hormones and appetite all push on both sides of that equation.
  • They change how much you want to eat, and how much you burn.

What changes after 40

  • Your thyroid and the menopause matter.
  • But they work through calories, not around them.
  • They can make you hungrier, more tired and less active.
  • Poor sleep does the same.
  • You crave sugar and carbs, and training feels twice as hard.
  • And you lose muscle if you don't use it.
  • Lose weight fast without protein and workouts designed for your body, and some of that weight is muscle.

Why your numbers are probably wrong

  • Online calorie calculators can be 20 to 30% out, and more for older people.
  • Food labels can be up to 20% out.
  • So treat any number as a starting point, not a promise.
  • "I eat 1,000 calories and I don't lose weight."
  • Most of the time, that means people eat more than they think.
  • A little bite here, a little bite there, and it all adds up.
  • Write down everything you eat and drink for seven days.
  • Be honest, and the extras will tell the story.

The weekend leak

  • Say you keep a 500-calorie deficit every weekday.
  • Then the weekend comes: drinks, takeaways, snacks, a "treat" that becomes two days.
  • About 4,000 extra calories at the weekend can wipe out the whole week.
  • That's why so many people say, "I'm good all week and nothing happens."
  • Here's your habit: check your weekend.
  • Write it down, Friday night to Sunday night, just like the weekdays.
  • Plug the leak, and the week starts working again.

Keto is hunger control

  • High-protein and keto eating help you eat less without trying.
  • They work because they control your hunger.
  • Build your meals around quality protein, some healthy fats and a few carbohydrates.
  • First, we work out your fat-free weight.
  • Then we move from there and set your own protein target.
  • It's different for men and women.
  • Add green vegetables to fill you up with almost no carbs.
  • Cut the sugar and the sugary drinks.
  • Then do your 20-minute workouts with Coach Adrian, designed for your body, so the weight you lose is fat, not muscle.

Coach Adrian's view

  • Calories count.
  • Hormones count.
  • Neither one is an excuse.
  • Keto keeps the hunger down, protein keeps the muscle on, and the deficit does the rest.
  • Build it step by step, not with a crash diet.
  • No guesswork. No voodoo. No yo-yo. No magic pills or potions. Just a proven plan that works.

Sources

  1. Dr John Berardi, Precision Nutrition (Canada), 2020, updated 2026: Calories in vs. out? Or hormones? The debate is finally over
This article is general information, not medical advice. If you're not sure of anything, do seek some medical advice.

Lose the weight, keep the muscle

Keto, protein and 20-minute workouts, step by step with Coach Adrian.

Weight loss & nutrition →
Start my 14 days free